▸ Column · Present day — the soft, self-congratulatory modern world Schmidt holds in contempt; rooftop bars and group texts
RED SKULL replies.
Replied to by Red Skull, with a rebuttal from Captain America.
The letter
I saw something I can't unsee. A woman I've known since university — call her Priya — has been with the same man three years. She just declined a position abroad rather than be apart from him. Last weekend, across the city, I watched him at a bar with his arm around another woman, calling her his girlfriend in front of his friends. I was so stunned I photographed it. The pictures have sat in my phone for five days while I eat my way through a pantry's worth of chips and listen to Priya happily plan their anniversary trip. Every cheerful text she sends turns my stomach. Do I detonate her life with what I know — or is there some version of events where I've misread everything and destroy her happiness for nothing?
Red Skull replies
Five days. You held proof in your hand for five days and spent it on chips. Begin there, specimen, because that is the only fact in your letter that is actually about you.
You imagine you have written to me with a moral question. You have not. You have submitted a status report, and the status is plain: you are a witness, never a participant. You photograph the wound and then you nurse it in private, hoping the dilemma will resolve itself so that no one may blame the one who watched. This is not delicacy. It is the instinct of the herd — to see, to record, to wait for permission.
Observe your Priya, too. She surrendered a future across the sea for a man who was never hers exclusively. Sentiment cost her London before he ever cost her anything. The weak arrange their own ruin and call it love.
So. Will the truth wound her? Of course. Her discomfort is not an injustice — it is information, long overdue. Deliver it or do not. But do not pretend the agony is moral. The agony is that you have learned you are not someone events run through. You are someone they happen to. That is the autopsy. Schwach.
— Red Skull
Captain America weighs in
Don't listen to the man who measures people by who's strong enough to step on whom. Here's the principle, plain: Priya's being lied to by somebody she rearranged her whole life for. That's the bully in this — Marcus, the coward kissing somebody new while she books his plane tickets. Not you.
Schmidt calls your waiting weakness. I call it being human and scared, and scared's allowed. Fear just doesn't get the deciding vote. Sit down with her — in person, photos in hand, no speech. "I saw something. You deserve to know." It'll hurt her and it'll cost you. Tell her anyway. Lying to spare somebody's feelings is its own betrayal. She'll want the friend who told the truth.
— Captain America
▸ Read next