▸ Column · Modern Gotham syndicate noir — a neighborhood bakery on the wrong side of the Diamond District
THE PENGUIN replies.
Replied to by The Penguin, with a rebuttal from Batman.
The letter
A pipe burst at 2 a.m. and flooded my little bakery the night before the biggest selling day of the year — every tray I'd prepped since midnight, gone. I posted a tearful note to the neighborhood group mostly to explain the Closed sign I'd be hanging. By dawn there were sixty-some replies and my friend Dara had marshaled eleven people with mops, a shop vac, a borrowed burner, and more butter than I knew what to do with. We salvaged a stripped-down menu, sold out by mid-morning, and the regulars passed a hat that covered my insurance deductible and then some. I don't have a problem. I've just been wandering around dazed ever since — undone by how fast strangers turned into something like family — and I needed to tell somebody.
The Penguin replies
My dear baker, you have stumbled into a fortune and you're too misty-eyed to count it. Waugh-waugh! Let an emperor of crime translate for you. Eleven souls waded through your floodwater at four in the morning. That is not "family," you sentimental wren — that is eleven markers, eleven debts written in your favor, signed in mop water and borrowed butter. The hat they passed? Seed capital. Now you owe a thank-you, and in the owing you've learned the one law worth knowing: in this city, the birds of prey are the ones holding the umbrellas, and you've just been handed a very fine umbrella indeed.
So waddle, don't drown. Remember every name. Dara especially — the one who organizes a crowd at four a.m. is the one to keep close and watch closer. Bake them their favorites, learn their troubles, become the warm light on the corner that everyone leans toward. A network of grateful regulars is worth more than any vault on the Diamond District. I built an empire from a beak and a sneer; you've a flooded oven and the loyalty of a whole block. Don't squander it on weeping. Invest it. The croissants are merely the cover story.
— The Penguin
Batman weighs in
Cobblepot counts favors because no one ever gave him one for free. That's his whole tragedy in a sentence. Don't take his ledger.
Eleven people showed up because they wanted to. No debt. No markers. No umbrella over your head. Let it stay that way.
But learn this. Men like the Penguin smell a generous block the way a rat smells grain. They arrive later — smiling, "investing," offering to help. When they do, remember who came at four a.m. with a mop and asked for nothing.
Remember the names. Not as debts. As a wall. I'll be watching the ones who try to climb it.
— Batman
▸ Read next