▸ Column · Post-war Hidden Leaf shinobi world; the letter-writer is a parent returning from extended ANBU wartime duty, adapted from a contemporary military deployment scenario
ITACHI UCHIHA replies.
Replied to by Itachi Uchiha, with a rebuttal from Sasuke Uchiha.
The letter
I came home from an extended ANBU assignment fourteen months ago, and my own children treat me like a guest who has already overstayed. My daughter Emily just turned six; she still asks my wife in a whisper whether "the shinobi" is staying for supper, and she flinches when I raise my voice even slightly. My son Joe is nine and remembers the father who used to wrestle with him on the tatami and let him win — the quiet, watchful man I am now disappoints him in ways he cannot name. Last week I offered to take them for dango and both of them checked with their mother first, as if they needed her clearance to be alone with me. I had to leave the room before they could see my face. I am working with a specialist, I know I am not the same person who left on mission, but I do not know how to become someone my children will run toward instead of away from. How do I earn back children who were too small to remember what it felt like to love me? —Ghost in My Own Home
Itachi Uchiha replies
The grief in this is real, and you should not be asked to carry it lightly.
But I want to press gently on the frame you are using. You say earn back, as though your children keep a ledger somewhere and the debt is yours to pay. A six-year-old who whispers "the shinobi" and looks to her mother for permission — that child is not withholding love. She is reaching for safety in the only shape available to her. She has no ledger. She has a gap where a familiar figure used to be.
I know what love looks like when it cannot find a door to walk through. I lost my brother's trust deliberately, for years, because I judged it the only way to keep him alive. Your situation is nothing like mine — you left for duty, not by design. But love wearing the wrong shape looks the same from either side of the distance. Your daughter's whisper is not the absence of love. It is love that has not yet found a form it recognizes as safe.
The frame of earning will exhaust you and mean nothing on their end. Be small enough for them to reach instead. Let Joe wrestle you to the floor — not as a performance of the father he misses, but because you are simply there this Saturday, and the one after. Let Emily see your face, even when it is hard. Especially then. Stay in the room.
The love is not gone. It is only waiting for a shape it can walk through.
— Itachi Uchiha
Sasuke Uchiha weighs in
Itachi will tell you the love is still there, waiting. He's not wrong.
I was that kid. I was younger than Joe when I started measuring whether the person I depended on would be the same from one room to the next. So I'll tell you what Emily's whisper actually is: not withheld love. A risk assessment. Can I predict him? If I misread the room, what happens?
Stop asking how to earn it back. Wrong question. Your children aren't running a tab on love. They're asking whether you're readable.
You become readable by being the same in small ways, enough times that it stops being a question. Not softer — that's not what this is. Not the man you were before you shipped out; he's gone, and grieving him in front of them helps no one. Joe's father isn't coming back. Whoever you are now — be that, consistently. Quiet? Be quietly there. Jumpy? Don't perform calm. Just be the same kind of jumpy, predictably, until they've mapped you.
Itachi finds the beautiful shape for things. Here's the functional one: safe doesn't mean gentle. Safe means readable. That's what they're waiting for.
— Sasuke Uchiha
▸ Read next