▸ Column · Modern day, grounded comic register — Magneto answering a letter through the lens of a Holocaust survivor who reads every wound as a question of power held and power surrendered.
MAGNETO replies.
Replied to by Magneto, with a rebuttal from Professor X.
The letter
I'm 34. Last month I ran into the boy who made middle school a daily horror — for two solid years he'd pin me in the hallway between classes and call me "jug ears" until I started wearing my hair down through summer just to hide them. He was at a mutual friend's backyard birthday. The instant I saw his face my throat closed exactly the way it did when I was twelve, and I spent two hours pretending to be riveted by a garden hose instead of talking to anyone. Here's the maddening part: he obviously didn't recognize me, he was genuinely funny, and a friend mentioned he does a lot of volunteer work with kids now. I don't want to spend the next thirty years seizing up at parties because of someone I knew for two years in 1999. But I can't tell if what I'm feeling is grief, leftover rage, or just shame that it still gets to me.
Magneto replies
You spent two hours studying a garden hose. Let us be precise about why. At twelve you were cornered each day by someone who could wound you and pay nothing for it, and no one — not a teacher, not a friend — altered that arithmetic. Your body learned the only lesson on offer: you are at his mercy. It has never forgotten, because no one ever taught it otherwise.
What seized your throat was not grief, nor rage, nor shame. It was your nervous system reporting, accurately, that the account was never settled.
Now — the man does charity with children, he is amusing, he did not know your face. I am unmoved, and so should you be. His pleasantness is weather; it is costless to him, and it is not the question. The question is whether you remain that defenseless child. You do not. You survived him with no armor at all, which means you are stronger than the boy who needed it.
So do not introduce yourself to earn his recognition. Never beg for a seat at a table where you were once simply dealt with. Stand in the room knowing he holds nothing over you now — and let the hose attend to itself.
— Magneto
Professor X weighs in
Erik would have you audit a backyard party in ledgers of power. I have loved the man a lifetime, and here he reaches for armor against a ghost. Look beneath it instead: the boy who taunted you was frightened of something — they always are — and the man now volunteering with children may be living proof that people grow past their cruelest year. That ought to comfort you, not arm you. You needn't befriend him. But the door you are guarding so fiercely is your own. The grip on your throat loosens not when you decide he holds nothing over you, but when you finally forgive the twelve-year-old who had no choice but to hide his ears.
— Professor X
▸ Read next