▸ Column · Modern Gotham — the letter lands with Harley Quinn, who started some kind of advice column or podcast because someone bet she wouldn't last a month at something constructive
HARLEY QUINN replies.
Replied to by Harley Quinn, with a rebuttal from Poison Ivy.
The letter
Eight months together, every single night — his toothbrush in my bathroom, his face at my sister's engagement party, a good-morning text that shows up like clockwork. And then his coworker asked if he had a girlfriend and he laughed and said "we're keeping it casual." Right in front of me. I've tried to bring up what we are twice; once he pivoted to whether I wanted pizza, once he pulled me into a hug like I was being adorable and not completely serious. Now my lease is up in September, and he keeps floating the idea of us getting a place together — which feels genuinely unhinged when he won't even admit we're dating. Am I building a future on something he refuses to name? And how do I get a real answer without it sounding like an ultimatum? — Nameless in Gotham
Harley Quinn replies
Oh, hon — you don't need an answer. You HAVE one. He said it out loud, in front of a witness, while you were standing right there: "we're keeping it casual." The question you keep asking isn't "what are we?" The question you're actually asking is "can I afford to believe what he already told me?"
That is a much harder question, and I know it personally, because I filled approximately forty notebooks with a version of it before I clocked what was really going on. I had a doctorate, I diagnosed people for a living, and I still spent years building a whole story around somebody who would never, not once, be officially on record as mine. So — grain of salt, cupcake — but also: I know this specific flavor of denial better than almost anyone.
Here's the thing about a guy who benefits from being loved without accountability: he's got all the best parts of you — the proximity, the mornings, the engagement party where you probably looked fantastic — and zero of the responsibility, because he never said the word. Someone who's genuinely bad at labels eventually says them when pushed. Someone who ACTIVELY picks "casual" in front of a coworker, then pivots to pizza when you try to name it? That's not shyness. That's a system that works real well for him.
You don't need a script. Next time he floats the moving-in idea, look him dead in the eye and ask "so what ARE we?" No giggle, no softening it into a joke. What he does in the next five seconds is your answer. If he deflects again, sweetie — that IS the answer. You're not building on something unnamed. You're building on the name he already gave it.
— Harley Quinn
Poison Ivy weighs in
Harley wants you to look him in the eye and demand the word like that's the prescription. Very dramatic. Very her. Darling, I've watched Harley beg to be named by someone who had no intention of doing it, and I can tell you from a front-row seat: the speech she's describing never worked as well as the silence that came after. You don't need his answer. You need to become the one who can leave. Stop irrigating what won't root itself. Cut the water. Let him feel the drought — that's when you find out what anything is actually made of, and when you stop needing to ask.
— Poison Ivy
▸ Read next