▸ Column · Attack on Titan — inside the walls, harvest-to-midsummer, Germanic-inflected civilian setting
EREN YEAGER replies.
Replied to by Eren Yeager, with a rebuttal from Mikasa Ackerman.
The letter
My husband Otto and I were together every night for years — that kind of closeness you stop thinking about until one day it's just gone. Last harvest season it stopped. No fight, no announcement. When I finally asked him, around midwinter, he said he was worn out from his post rotations — I believed him, or told myself I did — and then immediately started talking about a broken window shutter. That was months ago now.
We still kiss before he leaves for his shift. He sits right next to me at Magda's district games, holds my hand the whole time. He's not cold toward me. But the other part of it is like a locked room neither of us says a word about. I lie awake most nights trying to figure out which it is: is it me, is there someone else, or is there something he's too frightened to name? Honestly the not-knowing might be worse than any answer he could actually give.
Do I push for the real conversation even if it breaks the quiet we've got?
— Uncertain in Trost
Eren Yeager replies
The not-knowing is the cage. You understand that already — it's why you're lying awake in it every night.
You both agreed, somewhere along the way, to maintain this wall inside your own house and call it peaceful. I grew up inside walls people insisted kept us safe. They weren't safe. They were just agreed-upon.
He said "tired" and handed you a broken shutter. That's not neutral. You were asking about your marriage and he found an exit. People with nothing to hide don't need exits that convenient.
Go back. Ask again — clearly, in a moment where there's no shutter to retreat into. Not to start a war, not to blow down what you've built. Because you're already living in the dark with all three of your worst guesses at once, and none of them is better than the actual truth. You deserve to know what's in the room.
Here's what I have to split off and show you: my voice, followed all the way, says burn the house down to feel free. That's exactly where I took this conviction, and I drove it off a cliff. Wanting the truth is right. Torching everything because the silence has become unbearable — that's the poison, and it ends somewhere you don't want. Don't follow me past that line.
My mother never knew what I kept from her until it was too late. I still think about that.
— Eren Yeager
Mikasa Ackerman weighs in
He kissed you goodbye. He held your hand at the game. And when you asked him directly, he talked about a shutter. That's not one thing — that's three pieces of evidence, and they already point in the same direction.
Eren thinks the cage is the not-knowing. It isn't. The cage is lying awake every night, building three explanations in your head to avoid having to decide anything. A confession won't free you from that. Ask yourself a different question: what do you do with a man who's warm where people can see and somewhere else entirely in private? Start there. The conversation is beside the point.
— Mikasa Ackerman
▸ Read next