▸ Column · Present-day, adapted into mutant terms — the asker's hand tremor and stray static the visible mark of a latent mutation that drew the schoolyard cruelty.
MAGNETO replies.
Replied to by Magneto, with a rebuttal from Professor X.
The letter
I'm 34. Last month I turned a corner in a hardware store and there was Derek Okafor — the boy who used to knock my tray out of my hands and call me "Sparks" in front of the whole cafeteria, because my hands shake and throw off little arcs of static when I'm frightened. That tremor was the first sign anyone ever had that I'm a mutant. He recognized me, grinned, stuck out his hand: "Hey man, how've you been?" — as though none of it ever happened. I froze, gripping a box of tile adhesive, and couldn't make a sound. Then I drove home and sat in my car crying for twenty minutes, which appalled me. I have a good job, a partner I love; I was certain I'd left all this behind me. Why can one accidental run-in with someone who probably forgot me by graduation still hollow me out at my age? Is this normal, or is there something I've been dodging that I finally need to face?
Magneto replies
You ask whether your weeping in that car was a symptom of something broken in you. I will not let you keep asking such a question, because it is the wrong one, and it points the blade inward — exactly where the powerful would prefer it pointed.
Consider the cafeteria as it truly was. A boy who held everything; a boy who held nothing. You were not weak. You were outnumbered and small and marked by something you did not choose — I know precisely what that is. I was a child behind wire, made to wear a thing that told the world I was nothing. The body files such lessons whole. It does not consult your résumé before it remembers.
So his hand, extended, grinning — understand what it asked. It asked you to sign a release. To certify that nothing occurred, so that he might pay nothing for it. That is the only transaction on offer, and you owe it no signature.
Here is your leverage, and it is total: you built a life he has no vote in. That is the answer — not his absolution, not your "closure." Walk past. Grieve the boy if you must; never apologize for the grief. And never again mistake an accurate memory for a wound that needs curing.
— Magneto
Professor X weighs in
Erik reads only the room — who held the power, who held none — and stops there, as he always does. He never asks the other question. What was Derek Okafor, at fifteen, so frightened of that he had to make someone smaller than himself? In a lifetime of looking into people I have never once found cruelty that was not fear wearing a costume.
And those twenty minutes in the car were not about Derek's power. They were the boy you used to be, finally grieved by the man who survived him. That is a door, my friend — not a breach to be armored over.
Erik turned his grief into a weapon and called it strength. I have loved him my whole life, and watched precisely what it cost. Don't follow him through that door. Sit with your own a while longer.
— Professor X
▸ Read next