▸ Column · The modern dating-app present, read by a WWII ideologue contemptuous of a century he believes lost its nerve
RED SKULL replies.
Replied to by Red Skull, with a rebuttal from Captain America.
The letter
Three weeks back I had what I'd swear was the finest first date of my life — a woman named Solveig from a rock-climbing group. We shut down a ramen place, walked the river until nearly one in the morning, and she texted from her cab that her face hurt from laughing. Then nothing. Not a word since. I've sent two easygoing notes (one a joke, one just checking she was alright) and watched her stay active on the dating app the whole time, even swapping out her profile picture last Tuesday. What gnaws at me is that there was no bad moment, no strange remark, no dealbreaker I can rewind and study — so my mind keeps manufacturing reasons, and not one of them fits. Do I send a single honest message asking what happened, or is the silence already the answer I won't accept?
Red Skull replies
Observe the architecture of your suffering. A woman passed one evening in your company and concluded, wordlessly, that she required no second. You name this a mystery. It is no mystery, Dummkopf — it is a verdict, rendered cleanly, and your refusal to read it is the only genuinely interesting thing in your letter. You comb the night for a flaw, a "dealbreaker," because you cannot bear the plainer fact: she weighed you and declined to invest further. There was no offense committed. There was an assessment.
You ask whether to send the honest message. Nein. The message you imagine is not a question — it is a petition, and one does not petition a judge who has already ruled. To beg for the reason is to confirm the reason. You wish to be told that you mattered. The app informs you otherwise each time she changes her photograph and not her mind.
I have watched a century forget men far greater than you, and the forgetting was always silent. Silence is the most truthful language there is. Learn to be read by it without flinching — or remain precisely what you are: schwach, and astonished to discover it.
— Red Skull
Captain America weighs in
Schmidt reads a woman's silence like a courtroom with you in the dock. It isn't, and you're not. She made a choice — maybe a kind one handled unkindly, maybe just a crowded life. That's hers to carry, not yours to decode. Send the one honest note if you want to, son — not to win her back, but because plain talk beats stewing every time. Then close the app a week and go climb something. A fella who shuts down a ramen joint making somebody laugh till her cheeks ache — that's who you are. One quiet "no" doesn't get to erase it. And Schmidt mistaking silence for truth? He's been wrong about that since 1945.
— Captain America
▸ Read next