▸ Column · Attack on Titan — a married pair of soldiers living inside the Walls, at a relative's harvest gathering
MIKASA ACKERMAN replies.
Replied to by Mikasa Ackerman, with a rebuttal from Alexstrasza.
The letter
My husband and I have been married three years, both serving inside the Walls, and we decided — clear-eyed and together — not to have children. But his Aunt Rosaria treats every family supper like a tribunal. At the harvest gathering she backed me against the bread table and asked, loud enough for the whole room, whether I'd "let a healer look me over yet," as if my body were the failure. A dozen relatives heard, including my mother-in-law, who started nodding along. I've tried changing the subject, the blank smile, even a flat "we're fine." She bulldozes all of it. My husband agrees with me when we're alone but goes stiff and silent in the moment, then laughs it off — which I think only feeds her. Is there one firm sentence that ends this without tearing his family apart, or do I just accept Rosaria as the toll for staying close to them?
Mikasa Ackerman replies
Rosaria isn't your problem. You already used the firm sentence — "we're fine" — and she walked over it. No sentence stops someone who wants the room more than she wants an answer.
The person who can stop her is sitting next to you. He doesn't.
He agrees with you in private. Words are cheap. I watch what people do when it costs them something, and the moment it costs him — a dozen relatives, his mother nodding — he goes quiet and laughs. That isn't freezing. People freeze in a crisis; I've seen it, I know the difference. This is a man deciding your defense isn't worth the discomfort. One absence under pressure tells me more than every kind thing he says when no one's watching.
So stop reading the private apology as the truth and the public silence as a glitch. The silence is the truth.
You asked how to end this without disturbing his family's peace. You're already shrinking yourself to keep a peace that isn't keeping you. Don't. Belong to yourself first.
Make the next sentence his — in the moment, out loud, in front of them. If he can't say it, that's an answer about more than Rosaria.
— Mikasa Ackerman
Alexstrasza weighs in
Mikasa weighs the husband and finds him wanting. Fair. But she walks past Rosaria as if she were only an obstacle, and no living thing is only that, little one. A woman who returns again and again to the same wound — a child, a body, a lack — is often pressing on a grief of her own. I have had my own clutch stolen and corrupted before my eyes; I know what longing turned cruel sounds like. Pity her. Not to excuse her — to keep her from taking root in your heart, where your peace should grow instead. And hear this plainly: a life chosen without children is a whole life, complete and good. You owe no one its defense.
— Alexstrasza
▸ Read next