▸ Column · Modern grounded — present-day dating apps, a wine-bar first date
THE PUNISHER replies.
Replied to by The Punisher, with a rebuttal from Captain America.
The letter
I swiped right on a guy — call him Carl — whose five photos showed someone clean-shaven, dark curls, a runner's build. The man who sat down across from me at the wine bar last week was fifteen years older, balding, and wearing a flannel I eventually placed in a photo that had to be ten years old. When my face did something, he laughed it off — "everyone says the pictures don't do me justice." Except it was the opposite. I didn't want to be shallow, so I stayed for one drink, and now he's texting every day about a second date. How do I tell him the problem isn't that he's older — it's that he flat-out lied about who'd be walking in — without sounding like I'm rejecting him for his age?
The Punisher replies
You already know the answer or you wouldn't have written. So let me strip it down. The man didn't age badly. He lied. Decade-old photos aren't optimism, they're a misrepresentation, and he walked in counting on you being too polite to say so. He was right. You stayed for the drink. Now you're texting me asking how to reject him gently for being older — which is a problem he doesn't have, because that's not the problem.
Here's what's actually eating you. You're doing his lying for you. Twisting yourself into "am I shallow" so you never have to say one true sentence out loud. Stop carrying his dishonesty. That's his weight, not yours.
Tell him this, once, clean: the profile wasn't the man, and you don't build anything on someone who opens with a lie. Don't dress it up. Don't apologize for it. The clean truth is the kindest thing in the room even when it doesn't feel kind.
This is small, in the scheme of what's out there. A guy fudging an app is a long way from the things I deal with. But the muscle's identical — tell the truth, don't flinch, and you don't owe a liar a second date.
— The Punisher
Captain America weighs in
Frank's right about the lie, and right that you don't reward it with a second date. Here's where we part, friend. You don't tell him the truth because he earned the courtesy — he didn't. You tell him plain because that's who you are when nobody's grading you. So don't fire off a cold one-liner and call it honesty. Use your own words: the profile wasn't him, and that's a dealbreaker for you. Say it once, say it kind, and walk with your head up. The flannel fella's a coward for the lie. Don't let his cowardice talk you into a quieter one of your own.
— Captain America
▸ Read next